5 years ago#1
shun
Fresh Member
Blogs: 0
Forum: 2
Votes: 0

Need help on this.

"From the perspective of a student of American history, what are the 3 most important aspects of the Civil War to understand? Why are they the MOST important?"

Does anyone know?
I need help thanks!!

Answer
5 years ago#2
Guest
Blogs:
Forum: 0

dear shun,as for three aspects,do you mean at the start of the war ,half way thru the war,or at the end.at the beggining seems staterights to the south,in the north solidifying the usa,possibly the tariff issue,mistrust on both sides.later abolition of slavery.at the end the usa is aworld power.all can agree the cw is one of the dumbest things we done to each other is that an aspect?

Reply
5 years ago#3
shun
Fresh Member
Blogs: 0
Forum: 2
Votes: 0

I guess any "3 Most Important" aspects are fine. I need to write an short essay on this and I am having trouble finding the information and the "IMPORTANT ASPECTS".

I also need to know why they ARE important...

thanks

Reply
5 years ago#4
PeteHeron
Silver Member
Blogs: 6
Forum: 46
Votes: 1

Wow, what an awesome question, really!!! I think that question is so large it needs breaking down into many areas. I'll just answer quickly and spontaneously, okay?
1.Military Innovation
2.Impact on future of the USA
3.A set piece American Drama,with most events and characters known, that provides years of entertainment and thought to people like us.

1: Musket to Machinegun. Wooden boats to Iron Ships. Field medicine that led to things like Red Cross and huge improvements for all Americans. Strategy and Tactics: from standing and dying to learning concealment and cover; from static battles to use of rail and ship and cavalry for mobility, something not lost on Nazis later on. Oh, the list goes on. This is a fascinating aspect of Civil War.

2:Had war not happened, we would have remained at standing army of 15,000 men and aging wood boats. France and England would have surpassed us in those fields AND then France might well have taken Mexico for good, and England taken not only Canada but American West for good. It is the one GREAT benefit of this war: that we ended with an army and navy millions strong, with huge technical advances enabling us to become a world power. I shudder to think what would have happened had the war not occured.

3: Finally, and selfishly, the War provides you and me the opportunity to study a drama so well documented it's like being there. We can see an entire age, one distinct from ours, and how it went from horse/buggy to rail, ironships,etc; with planes, tanks,etc. in near future. With improvements for the civilian front. We get to know these people like family, don't we? Some may argue that it is not one of the three important things but if it were not, if we weren't fascinated, then who would care,eh?

In conclusion: you asked a dynamite question. It is one that could scare people away because it requires great thought and taking a stand on what a person thinks about that war. You challenged us and I thank you. Again, my answers were fast and spontaneous, but I think they reflect my basic opinions. Thanks again.

Reply
4 years ago#5
aloejandraaBkk.
Guest

Thats Right And It Was Also Named The Supply State

Reply
4 years ago#6
Ajhall
Master
Blogs: 28
Forum: 3,911
Votes: 13

Pete -- I came to this thread to review (and ultimately delete) a new and offensive post. In looking over the original question and your response, I was struck by your quick response. It was an excellent answer to a potentially complex question. Everything you said is dead on. I'd love to see you posting again, both here in the forum and with blogs (I subscribe to your blog). Your insights and knowledge are invaluable.

Reply
4 years ago#7
blueshawk1
Champion
Blogs: 7
Forum: 1,344
Votes: 6
PeteHeron wrote:

3: Finally, and selfishly, the War provides you and me the opportunity to study a drama so well documented it's like being there. We can see an entire age, one distinct from ours, and how it went from horse/buggy to rail, ironships,etc; with planes, tanks,etc. in near future. With improvements for the civilian front. We get to know these people like family, don't we?


I was going through some older threads and came across this, and while one and two are very good, I REALLY like number three!
Reply
4 years ago#8
tie
Guest

this is crazy

Reply
3 years ago#9
ddfd
Guest

there are many important aspects of the civil war such as the following:army camp life, soildiers daily routines,weaponary, uniformss, battle preparations and the aftermath of battles

Reply
2 years ago#10
LiveVegan
Ace
Blogs: 4
Forum: 701
Votes: 4

For a second I was thinking this topic was new...

As for the question, that is so hard to answer. The war was so complex and it affected and changed everything and everyone. On both sides, it challenged our moral fibers. Made heroes and cowards. They gave everything for integrity, honor and their beliefs. (Instead of world like today when it seems those fundamental characteristics are often for sale to the highest bidder.)

It gave us income taxes even.

Reply
2 years ago#11
macreverie
Ace
Blogs: 26
Forum: 986
Votes: 16

Well you are hitting close to the mark here anyway Vegan. I wish I had seen this when it was first posted

The three most important aspects of the war to understand are:

1. The war was fought over economic issues (everything else was just excuses)

2. There is nothing in the US Constitution to prevent a State from withdrawing from the union nor is there anything in the Constitution that allows the federal government to invade a State to prevent that separation.

3. lincoln et.al very carefully and very deliberately provoked the war and abe said as much himself. Why they did so is debatable but the fact that they did so is irrefutable.


Until one understands these three salient points they can understand very little about the war.

Reply
1 year ago#12
Austin Blacksmith
Guest

Wow!

Reply
By entering this site you declare you read and agreed to its Terms, Rules & Privacy and you understand that your use of the site's content is made at your own risk and responsibility.
Copyright © 2006 - 2015 American Civil War Forum